|
|
| Line 68: |
Line 68: |
| | </tr> | | </tr> |
| | <tr><td colspan=6 align=left valign=center> | | <tr><td colspan=6 align=left valign=center> |
| − | <font size=7 color=#51a7f9><b style="color: #51a7f9">Interview with Dr. Keith Pardee</b></font> | + | <font size=7 color=#51a7f9><b style="color: #51a7f9">Interview with Prof. Dr. Joyce Tait</b></font> |
| − | </td>
| + | |
| − | </tr>
| + | |
| − | | + | |
| − | <tr><td colspan=6 align=left valign=center>
| + | |
| − | <h3>Regarding his recent study <a class="myLink" href="http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0092867416305050">(Pardee et al., 2016)</a></h3>
| + | |
| | </td> | | </td> |
| | </tr> | | </tr> |
| Line 79: |
Line 74: |
| | <tr><td colspan=6 align=center valign=center> | | <tr><td colspan=6 align=center valign=center> |
| | <p> | | <p> |
| − | <b class="interviewQuestion">We read your paper from last year titled “Rapid, Low-Cost Detection of Zika Virus Using | + | <b class="interviewQuestion">What difference can synthetic biology bring to the world? How significant or relevant can it be for future generations?</b> <br><br> |
| − | Programmable Biomolecular Components” and we wanted to know, what led you to
| + | <i>Prof. Tait</i>: Clearly very significant and relevant for future generations. The answer to this question for Europeans will depend on the EU being very much smarter than it is today in deciding how to regulate the technology.</p> |
| − | use β-galactosidase as a colored readout?</b> <br><br>
| + | |
| − | <i>Dr. Pardee</i>: One of the reasons was because of the potential for enzyme activity to amplify the output signal. | + | |
| − | Unlike fluorescent reporters (e.g. GFP), a single molecule of enzyme reporter can churn through substrate to create many molecules of color (chlorophenol red). The other reason was even more practical. With the use of a color-based system, the diagnostic processes occurring at the molecular level on paper can be determined with the naked eye. Therefore in low resource settings there is no need for UV lights, electronics and camera.</p>
| + | |
| | </td> | | </td> |
| | </tr> | | </tr> |
| Line 89: |
Line 81: |
| | <tr class="lastRow"><td colspan=6 align=center valign=center> | | <tr class="lastRow"><td colspan=6 align=center valign=center> |
| | <p> | | <p> |
| − | <b class="interviewQuestion">What was your motivation to build that detector on your study?</b> <br><br> | + | <b class="interviewQuestion">There are ethical issues for the use of genetically modified organisms irrespective of the severity and area of research. Do you think this should change and if yes how could we overcome the ethical issues better?</b> <br><br> |
| − | <i>Dr. Pardee</i>: The electronic optical reader developed by Tom Ferrante allows users to track multiple reactions at the same time. The reader also introduces the potential for quantification. These processes are semi-quantitative and so with this information you can start to interpret your data as more than just positive or negative for a pathogen. At this time, we don’t have the precision to determine the exact concentration of your pathogen (e.g. Zika virus), but you may be able to say this is a high titer or a low titer individual. Also, user accessibility, if you can automate the reading of tests, as in digital pregnancy tests, you can make it easier for users.</p> | + | <i>Prof. Tait</i>: I don´t think there are any genuinely ethical issues. There are some potential risk issues that we can deal with through effective regulation and there will be some issues related to societal impacts where jobs in one sector will be replaced by jobs in another sector, and possibly another country (best dealt with by effective government policies, not by restricting the use of particular technologies). Regarding how to overcome them, we could start by reducing the disproportionate, undemocratic influence of some advocacy groups on government decision making.</p> |
| | </td> | | </td> |
| | </tr> | | </tr> |
| | | | |
| − | <tr><td colspan=6 align=left valign=center>
| |
| − | <h3>Regarding our project</h3>
| |
| − | </td>
| |
| − | </tr>
| |
| | | | |
| | <tr><td colspan=6 align=center valign=center> | | <tr><td colspan=6 align=center valign=center> |
| | <p> | | <p> |
| − | <b class="interviewQuestion">What do you think about the problem of antibiotic resistance and the ways to prevent | + | <b class="interviewQuestion">The advances in scientific research has provided the nucleic acid-based point-of-care (POC) detection systems, the ability to detect any mutation in the genome, HIV infection, paternity, etc. Should it be used by individuals in their homes for detecting pathogens or for conducting different biological tests? What would be your personal concerns regarding this?</b> <br><br> |
| − | it?</b> <br><br> | + | <i>Prof. Tait</i>: Yes, if these advances are to help to deal with the AMR (antimicrobial resistance) problem they will need to be point-of-care and this could include being used by people in their homes and, particularly important, by farmers in diagnosing disease in their animals. Of course this may need to be backed up by professional verification, but the rapidity of read-out is equally important. Regarding the other issues listed, the urgency is less and so there would be less need for POC testing, but I would not have a problem with it. </p> |
| − | <i>Dr. Pardee</i>: We should continue to advocate responsible use for antibiotics in agriculture and medicine. With low cost and accessible tools like your team is building, it may be possible to identify antibiotic resistance early on and enable better containment and patient treatment.</p> | + | |
| | </td> | | </td> |
| | </tr> | | </tr> |
| Line 109: |
Line 96: |
| | <tr><td colspan=6 align=center valign=center> | | <tr><td colspan=6 align=center valign=center> |
| | <p> | | <p> |
| − | <b class="interviewQuestion">We have some problems getting the Cas13a lyophilized into paper. Do you have any | + | <b class="interviewQuestion">Any opinions on the problem of antibiotic resistance and ways to prevent it?</b> <br><br> |
| − | low-cost suggestion for us?</b> <br><br>
| + | <i>Prof. Tait</i>: This is too big a question to answer here, but rapid diagnostics have to be high on the list. See attached report on this. |
| − | <i>Dr. Pardee</i>: An interesting new paper (Karig et al., 2017) uses trehalose as a cryoprotectant for cell free-reactions. The trehalose is present in organisms like tardigrades (water bears) and helps to preserve protein stability while samples are dry or at elevated temperatures. | + | |
| | </p> | | </p> |
| | </td> | | </td> |
| Line 118: |
Line 104: |
| | <tr class="lastRow"><td colspan=6 align=center valign=center> | | <tr class="lastRow"><td colspan=6 align=center valign=center> |
| | <p> | | <p> |
| − | <b class="interviewQuestion">Did you ever considered using as a colorimetric readout such as gold nanoparticles?</b> <br><br>
| |
| − | <i>Dr. Pardee</i>: I think gold nanoparticles are an interesting option for colorimetric outputs and you can borrow much from what has already been done.
| |
| − | </p>
| |
| − | </td>
| |
| − | </tr>
| |
| − |
| |
| − | <tr><td colspan=4 align=left valign=center>
| |
| − | <h3>Regarding the Synthetic Biology field</h3>
| |
| − | </td>
| |
| − | </tr>
| |
| − |
| |
| − | <tr><td colspan=4 align=center valign=center>
| |
| − | <p>
| |
| − | <b class="interviewQuestion">What difference can Synthetic Biology bring to the world? How significant or relevant
| |
| − | can it be for future generations?</b> <br><br>
| |
| − | <i>Dr. Pardee</i>: As synthetic biologists we have a responsibility to be transparent and to actively communicate with the public. We cannot wait for the public to come to us, instead we need to ensure that the public knows what we are doing and why we are doing it. This will help to prevent misunderstandings and rejection of technologies, like we have seen with genetically modified plants in parts of the world.
| |
| − | </p>
| |
| − | <p>
| |
| − | Synthetic Biology has incredible potential to solve a lot of the big challenges of the day and I think probably the biggest one is inequity. In Canada, where I live, we are fortunate to have access to high-quality food and health care and sufficient energy, but unfortunately this is not the case in many parts of the world. I think that synthetic biology and biological engineering (and science in general) can serve to correct this inequality by creating low cost, accessible technologies.
| |
| − | </p>
| |
| − | <p>
| |
| − | The work that we are doing in our lab is focused on improving access to health care. Using cell-free technologies that are biosafe, we are developing low cost diagnostics and platforms for the manufacture of protein-based therapeutics, like vaccines. There are many other ways to use Synthetic Biology, and the nice part, from a scientist’s perspective, is that we are in early days and the space is wide open. So you can pursue whatever drives you and see where your creativity takes you. That´s exciting.
| |
| − | </p>
| |
| − | </td>
| |
| − | <td colspan=2>
| |
| − | <p style="text-align: center">
| |
| − | <i class="quotation">"As synthetic biologists we have a real responsibility to be transparent and to
| |
| − | communicate with the public actively, not just waiting for the public to come to us but we need
| |
| − | to see that the public knows what we are doing why we are doing it."<i>
| |
| − | </p>
| |
| − | </td>
| |
| − | </tr>
| |
| − |
| |
| − |
| |
| − | <tr>
| |
| − | <td colspan=2>
| |
| − | <p style="text-align: center">
| |
| − | <i class="quotation">"I am very aware that some people are very concerned
| |
| − | about GMOS and in some cases, there are ways just like any technology that it could be misused.
| |
| − | But that is something that is shared with pretty much any technology. I think the benefits of the
| |
| − | potential for this technology vastly outweighs the risks."<i>
| |
| − | </p>
| |
| − | </td>
| |
| − | <td colspan=4 align=center valign=center>
| |
| − | <p>
| |
| − | <b class="interviewQuestion">There are ethical issues for the use of genetically modified organisms irrespective of the
| |
| − | severity and area of research. Do you think this should change and if yes how could we
| |
| − | overcome the ethical issues better?</b> <br><br>
| |
| − | <i>Dr. Pardee</i>: Scientists actively support practices of containment of GMOs during the development of technologies and the evaluation of safety. Policies are doing what they were intended to do and researchers follow them. But I am aware that some people are concerned about GMOS and in some cases, there is potential, just like any technology, for misuse. I think the benefits of the potential for biotechnologies vastly outweigh the risks when they are used in a well thought out regulatory framework. Again it is important to communicate with the public. Just like other big issues of our time (e.g. climate change, vaccine safety) it is facts, in lockstep with responsible use, that really needs to drive policy, fact-based policy is key.
| |
| − | </p>
| |
| − | </td>
| |
| − | </tr>
| |
| − |
| |
| − | <tr><td colspan=4 align=center valign=center>
| |
| − | <p>
| |
| − | <b class="interviewQuestion">What is your opinion on the Bio-Hacking movement? (The people that are trying to
| |
| − | bring synthetic biology to homes)
| |
| − | </b> <br><br>
| |
| − | <i>Dr. Pardee</i>: I think it´s exciting, distributed thinking, engaging young people and others keen to solve problems is great. We don’t need all solutions to come from institutions or companies. Think about how Apple or Microsoft started. But there are risks and so there needs to be regulations. For example, what are the DNA sequences being synthesized?
| |
| − | </p>
| |
| − | </td>
| |
| − | <td colspan=2>
| |
| − | <p style="text-align: center">
| |
| − | <i class="quotation">" We don’t need all solutions to come from institutions or
| |
| − | companies"<i>
| |
| − | </p>
| |
| − | </td>
| |
| − | </tr>
| |
| − |
| |
| − | <tr>
| |
| − | <td colspan=2>
| |
| − | <p style="text-align: center">
| |
| − | <i class="quotation">"Hopefully one day, consumers will be able to
| |
| − | order something in a place like the Amazon and see whether they have a viral or a bacterial
| |
| − | infection, to know if they need to visit a doctor or stay at home."<i>
| |
| − | </p>
| |
| − | </td>
| |
| − | <td colspan=4 align=center valign=center>
| |
| − | <p>
| |
| − | <b class="interviewQuestion">The advances in scientific research has provided the nucleic acid-based point-of-care
| |
| − | detection systems, the ability to detect anything (mutations in your genome, HIV
| |
| − | infection, paternity, etc.) Should it be used by individuals, in their home, for detecting
| |
| − | pathogens or conducting different biological tests? What would be your personal
| |
| − | concerns regarding this?</b> <br><br>
| |
| − | <i>Dr. Pardee</i>: I think the practical path forward is to extend the capability that is currently limited to clinical labs and hospitals, out to patients in a more distributed model. The first step might be the doctor´s office or the pharmacy. I could see it going further out to veterinarians and doctors in developing environments and rural hospitals.
| |
| − | </p>
| |
| − | </td>
| |
| − | </tr>
| |
| − |
| |
| − | <tr><td colspan=6 align=center valign=center>
| |
| − | <p>
| |
| − | <b class="interviewQuestion">Do you think there should be any limitations regarding the use of these types of
| |
| − | devices?</b> <br><br>
| |
| − | <i>Dr. Pardee</i>: Technology must be accompanied with regulations and consideration for the social implications. There are lots of places where portable testing for pathogens could do a lot of good, especially in low and middle-income countries.</p>
| |
| − | </td>
| |
| − | </tr>
| |
| − |
| |
| − | <tr><td colspan=6 align=center valign=center>
| |
| − | <p>
| |
| − | <b class="interviewQuestion">What are the future perspectives of Synthetic Biology in your opinion?</b> <br><br>
| |
| − | <i>Dr. Pardee</i>: : I am super excited about the future of Synthetic Biology and Bio-engineering. With continued and growing support from funding agencies, this is going to be an amazing field to be a scientist and there is a lot of potential to bring real benefits to the world. To think that you can use biology to transform carbon, hydrogen, oxygen, nitrogen, etc. into sensors, materials and therapeutics with what are essentially self-replicating machines is amazing and has the potential to catalyze incredible change.</p>
| |
| − | </td>
| |
| − | </tr>
| |
| − |
| |
| | | | |
| | | | |
