Difference between revisions of "Team:Fudan/Applied Design"

Line 35: Line 35:
  
 
</table>
 
</table>
 +
</div>
 +
 +
<div class="block main-text main-text">
 +
  <h class="HomeTitle dark-blue">SwordS</br></h>
 +
<h class="bold-text dark-blue"><center> enables antigen density dependent tri-response for therapeutic applications</center></h>
 +
  <h class="highlight-title dark-blue"></br></br>Abstract</h>
 +
  <p></br>Antigen density on tumor cells’ surface is heterogeneous. Current cellular immunotherapy only targets cells with high expression of specific tumor antigen. While this approach can improve the precision of recognition, it loses the opportunity to strategically treat tumor cells with different surface antigen densities. We are the first to propose a cellular immunotherapy platform, SwordS (SynNotch-Stripe system), that is capable of generating non-monotonic therapeutic responses to one tumor antigen with different surface densities. We demonstrated our concept with the following experiments. In combining a SynNotch module, which can recognize the antigen, and a Stripe module, which can sort intracellular signal, our engineered cells could generate antigen density dependent tri-response against the target cells with different densities of surface GFP, as well as membrane GPC3 (the tumor antigen of hepatocellular carcinoma). Both experimental data and mathematical simulation show that our platform not only reduces the on-target/off-tumor effects of the original SynNotch system, but also provides a combinational therapeutic solution to treat tumor at various states. We believe that SwordS is a promising platform for the next generation cellular immunotherapy. </br></br>
 +
</p>
 
</div>
 
</div>
  
  
 
<div class="block main-text main-text">
 
<div class="block main-text main-text">
   <h class="highlight-title dark-blue"><center></br></br></br>SwordS</br></center></h>
+
   <h class="highlight-title dark-blue">SwordS</br></h>
<h class="bold-text dark-blue"><center>Antigen density heterogeneity and limited treatment, </br>two obstacles in improving therapeutic effect and applicability of immunotherapy</center></h>
+
<h class="bold-text dark-blue">Antigen density heterogeneity and limited treatment, two obstacles in improving therapeutic effect and applicability of immunotherapy</h>
 
   <h class="highlight-title dark-blue"></br></br>Target antigen density heterogeneity</h>
 
   <h class="highlight-title dark-blue"></br></br>Target antigen density heterogeneity</h>
 
   <p></br>The expression of the antigen on individual cells within a given tumor is different or heterogeneous. A solid tumor mass consists of numerous tumor cells. In these tumor cells, some may express relatively less tumor antigens, others may express relatively more tumor antigens. Meanwhile, a given tumor antigen is not only expressed on malignant cells, but may also be expressed on normal cells at a low level <font color="#004a84">(Figure 1A)</font>. Thus, normal cells expressing low level of tumor antigens subsequently should not be targeted, otherwise would casuse complications. Carefully control the on-target/off-tumor effect is critical for the success of immunotherapy. <font color="#004a84">(Figure 1B)</font> </br></br>
 
   <p></br>The expression of the antigen on individual cells within a given tumor is different or heterogeneous. A solid tumor mass consists of numerous tumor cells. In these tumor cells, some may express relatively less tumor antigens, others may express relatively more tumor antigens. Meanwhile, a given tumor antigen is not only expressed on malignant cells, but may also be expressed on normal cells at a low level <font color="#004a84">(Figure 1A)</font>. Thus, normal cells expressing low level of tumor antigens subsequently should not be targeted, otherwise would casuse complications. Carefully control the on-target/off-tumor effect is critical for the success of immunotherapy. <font color="#004a84">(Figure 1B)</font> </br></br>
 
</p>
 
</p>
 
</div>
 
</div>
 +
 
<div>
 
<div>
 
<center><img width="50%" src="https://static.igem.org/mediawiki/2017/8/8e/Figure1.jpg"></center>
 
<center><img width="50%" src="https://static.igem.org/mediawiki/2017/8/8e/Figure1.jpg"></center>
 
</div>
 
</div>
 +
 
<div class="block main-text main-text">
 
<div class="block main-text main-text">
 
   <h class="highlight-title dark-blue"></br></br>Limited treatment cannot suit all cases</h>
 
   <h class="highlight-title dark-blue"></br></br>Limited treatment cannot suit all cases</h>
Line 57: Line 67:
 
<div class="block main-text notation ">
 
<div class="block main-text notation ">
 
   <br /><br />
 
   <br /><br />
   <h class="highlight-title dark-blue fold-trigger">Read more: Current methods to improve recognition and their imperfections</h>
+
   <h class="bold-text dark-blue fold-trigger"><i>Read more: Current methods to improve recognition and their imperfections</i></h>
 
   <div class="folded">
 
   <div class="folded">
 
     <p><br/>
 
     <p><br/>
Line 74: Line 84:
 
   </div>
 
   </div>
 
</div>
 
</div>
 +
 +
  
 
<div class="block main-text main-text">
 
<div class="block main-text main-text">

Revision as of 15:00, 30 October 2017

SwordS
enables antigen density dependent tri-response for therapeutic applications


Abstract


Antigen density on tumor cells’ surface is heterogeneous. Current cellular immunotherapy only targets cells with high expression of specific tumor antigen. While this approach can improve the precision of recognition, it loses the opportunity to strategically treat tumor cells with different surface antigen densities. We are the first to propose a cellular immunotherapy platform, SwordS (SynNotch-Stripe system), that is capable of generating non-monotonic therapeutic responses to one tumor antigen with different surface densities. We demonstrated our concept with the following experiments. In combining a SynNotch module, which can recognize the antigen, and a Stripe module, which can sort intracellular signal, our engineered cells could generate antigen density dependent tri-response against the target cells with different densities of surface GFP, as well as membrane GPC3 (the tumor antigen of hepatocellular carcinoma). Both experimental data and mathematical simulation show that our platform not only reduces the on-target/off-tumor effects of the original SynNotch system, but also provides a combinational therapeutic solution to treat tumor at various states. We believe that SwordS is a promising platform for the next generation cellular immunotherapy.

SwordS
Antigen density heterogeneity and limited treatment, two obstacles in improving therapeutic effect and applicability of immunotherapy

Target antigen density heterogeneity


The expression of the antigen on individual cells within a given tumor is different or heterogeneous. A solid tumor mass consists of numerous tumor cells. In these tumor cells, some may express relatively less tumor antigens, others may express relatively more tumor antigens. Meanwhile, a given tumor antigen is not only expressed on malignant cells, but may also be expressed on normal cells at a low level (Figure 1A). Thus, normal cells expressing low level of tumor antigens subsequently should not be targeted, otherwise would casuse complications. Carefully control the on-target/off-tumor effect is critical for the success of immunotherapy. (Figure 1B)



Limited treatment cannot suit all cases


Carcinogenesis is a gradual progress driven by the accumulation of mutations. Tumor cells are highly heterogeneous in their surface tumor antigen expression(1), thus immune resistance(2), sensitivity to the treatment and so on. Meanwhile, efficient recognition by immunotherapy, as one of the fundamental challenges for solid tumors, is still in the way comparing with exciting results shown in treating hematological cancers(3).Currently, most existing immunotherapies exhaust in trying multiple methods to improve recognition(4-6), without considerating tumor heterogeneity. They focus narrowly on finding an ideal tumor antigen as the target and hope to generate a effective therapeutic response – monotonic response.We believe these conventional one-size-fits-all immunotherapies cannot adapt itself to all complex disease occasions in various types of tumors.(Figure 1B)



Read more: Current methods to improve recognition and their imperfections


Current methods to improve recognition are not perfect
Emerging methods to improve recognizing precision, like dual recognition (6,7)and tunable sensitivity (5), have been proved capableof eliminating specific tumor cells. However,these methods cannot completely solve the problem.

Specific tumor antigens for dual recognition is hard to find
The first step for immunotherapy is to select a highly specific tumor antigen as the target. However, qualified candidates for tumor antigens are rare in most cases. Taking HCC (hepatocellular carcinoma) as an example, although HCC-associated antigens, like EpCAM(8), NY-ESO-1(9), and GPC3(10), are potential targets of cellular immunotherapies for advanced HCC. However, only GPC3, is wildly accepted as the tumor antigen of HCC owing to its high specificity.(6,11,12). Only one tumor antigen for HCC prevents the use of dual recognition.

Tunable sensitivity requires optimized scFv– it is very get
The affinity of single-chain variable fragment (scFv) is essentialfor recognition. Even though recently highthroughput methods have been developed to screen forscFvs with different affinity to the same antigen(13), specialized knowledge and high expense render it impossible to perform inall laboratories. Only one or two laboratories around the world have the capability to develop scFv with tunable sensitivity.



One important theory of traditional Chinese medicine: suit the remedy to the case


Tumor in different states need different treatments. To develop rational combined therapy, the key question is how to accurately manifest tumors’ condition. Fortunately, with improved understanding of oncogenesis and emerging therapies, clinical trials of rational combined therapy have become possible(14,15). Through investigation, we found that antigen density heterogeneity, tumor antigen level and expression pattern are associated with disease progression(16).Thus, Antigen density heterogeneity could be used to develop rational combined immunotherapy.

Here, we report the “SwordS”, SynNotch-Stripe system, which can spontaneously generate non-monotonic responses by targetingdifferent surface tumor antigen density of tumor cells at different states.(Figure 2)