Difference between revisions of "Team:Groningen/HP/Silver"

Line 48: Line 48:
 
<button onclick="accordion('acc1')" class="w3-button w3-block"><h3>Rathenau Institute - 14 April</h3></button>
 
<button onclick="accordion('acc1')" class="w3-button w3-block"><h3>Rathenau Institute - 14 April</h3></button>
 
<div id="acc1" class="w3-hide" style="text-align:left;">
 
<div id="acc1" class="w3-hide" style="text-align:left;">
At the beginning of our iGEM adventure we were invited by the Rathenau Institute, an institute which promotes safe and ethical research, to visit their introduction to the iGEMmers Guide To The Future. Along with an explanation what that is, we had speed dates with Human Practices experts from the Rathenau and RIVM (government institute for health and environment). Before this event we decided to make a DNA detector, but were not yet sure in what way. We had several option, but after the talks with experts we decided to focus on one specific project; a bacteriophages detection system for the dairy industry. We used the iGEMmers guide during the beginning or our project to explore our human practices options and had skype conversation with Zoe Robaey. She guided us where to start with human practices, such as who to contact, and gave us helpful tips for the deisgn of our 'Outbreak!' game.
+
At the beginning of our iGEM adventure we were invited by the Rathenau Institute, an institute which promotes safe and ethical research, to visit their introduction to the iGEMmers "Guide To The Future" (link)?. We also participated speed dates with Human Practices experts from the Rathenau and RIVM (government institute for health and environment). Before this event, we decided on making a DNA detection system. We were still unsure on the different aspects of implementation. After evaluating several options, receiving critical feedback and advice from experts in their respective fields we decided to focus on one specific project; a bacteriophages detection system for the dairy industry. We made use of the iGEMmers guide during the beginning of our project to explore our human practices opportunities with a skype call with Zoe Robaey. She guided us on where to start, who to contact, and how to design our 'Outbreak!' game.
 
</div>
 
</div>
 
<hr class="small">
 
<hr class="small">
Line 54: Line 54:
 
<button onclick="accordion('acc2')" class="w3-button w3-block"><h3>Jacques Hille - 20 June</h3></button>
 
<button onclick="accordion('acc2')" class="w3-button w3-block"><h3>Jacques Hille - 20 June</h3></button>
 
<div id="acc2" class="w3-hide" style="text-align:left;">
 
<div id="acc2" class="w3-hide" style="text-align:left;">
To gain insights of the impact of using GMOs in the food industry we contacted dr. J. Hille, among other a lecturer of Biotechnology course unit at the University of Groningen. Here we discussed the general differences between European and American legislation concerning GMO and the public opinion of GMOs in general. Dr. J. Hille was kind enough to give us useful directions and connections, such as Jeantine Lunshof and pointed us towards issues we should take into account before advancing our project.  
+
To gain insights of the impact of using GMOs in the food industry we contacted Dr. J. Hille, among others, a lecturer of Biotechnology course unit at the University of Groningen. Here we discussed the general differences between European and American legislation concerning GMO use and the public perception of GMOs in general. Dr. J. Hille was kind enough to give us useful directions and connections, such as Jeantine Lunshof and pointed us towards issues we should take into account before further advancing with our project.  
 
</div>
 
</div>
 
<hr class="small">
 
<hr class="small">
Line 60: Line 60:
 
<button onclick="accordion('acc3')" class="w3-button w3-block"><h3>ILT</h3></button>
 
<button onclick="accordion('acc3')" class="w3-button w3-block"><h3>ILT</h3></button>
 
<div id="acc3" class="w3-hide" style="text-align:left;">
 
<div id="acc3" class="w3-hide" style="text-align:left;">
Cathalijne van Beekvelt works for the ILT. This is the Dutch Inspection of Living environment and Transport. We contacted her because we wanted more information about the regulations that would limit us in bringing our product on the market. She gave us the contact information of Rob Duba, because he knows more about the policies regarding GMOs.
+
Cathalijne van Beekvelt works for the ILT. This is the Dutch Inspection of Living environment and Transport. We saught information about the regulations that could limit our products use. She gave us the contact information of Rob Duba, who might be of further assistance regarding the regulative challenges.
 
</div>
 
</div>
 
<hr class="small">
 
<hr class="small">
Line 66: Line 66:
 
<button onclick="accordion('acc4')" class="w3-button w3-block"><h3>RIVM</h3></button>
 
<button onclick="accordion('acc4')" class="w3-button w3-block"><h3>RIVM</h3></button>
 
<div id="acc4" class="w3-hide" style="text-align:left;">
 
<div id="acc4" class="w3-hide" style="text-align:left;">
Multiple times, we had a talk with Jaco Westra from the RIVM. The RIVM is the National Institute for Health and Environment. The RIVM provided us with funding and we worked on their assignment where we took safety as the most important aspect of our project. The title of the assignment was ‘Thinking before doing’. Essentially, think about the safety of your product, before you start developing it. We eventually presented all of the safety aspects, we believe to be important, in a card game which is both fun and educative. You can read more about 'Outbreak!' *here link*. Jaco was our contact person during this safety assignment. He gave great tips on how to handle legislation. He also gave us some help with who we could contact for more information, such as Wouter Ghering and ILT.
+
Multiple times, we had contact with Jaco Westra from the RIVM. RIVM provided us with funding and in turn, we tried to work on an assignment to continuously improve upon security aspects of our project. The title of the assignment was ‘Thinking before doing’. We eventually presented all of the safety aspects, we believe to be of relevance, in a card game which is both fun and educative. You can read more about 'Outbreak!' *here link*. Jaco was our contact person during this safety assignment. He gave great tips on how to handle legislation and on further points of contact, such as Wouter Ghering and ILT.
 
</div>
 
</div>
 
<hr class="small">
 
<hr class="small">
Line 72: Line 72:
 
<button onclick="accordion('acc5')" class="w3-button w3-block"><h3>Jeantine Lunshof - 22 June</h3></button>
 
<button onclick="accordion('acc5')" class="w3-button w3-block"><h3>Jeantine Lunshof - 22 June</h3></button>
 
<div id="acc5" class="w3-hide" style="text-align:left;">
 
<div id="acc5" class="w3-hide" style="text-align:left;">
Jeantine Lunshof works as a bioethicist at the Church laboratory in Boston. We contacted her in the beginning of our project to get a general view on ethics in the field of synthetic biology. After explaining the general idea of our project, she told us something about her work at the Church lab. Together we thought about a story which would be interesting for the public and would not scare them of.  
+
Jeantine Lunshof works as a bioethicist at the Church laboratory in Boston. We contacted her in the beginning of our project to educate ourselves on ethical dimensions in the field of synthetic biology. After introducing general idea of our project, she told us something about her work at the Church lab. Together we thought about a story which would be interesting as well as not repulsive for the public.  
Jeantine also mentioned that the consumer of dairy products is in our case a very low stakeholder. This definitely does not mean we should set them aside. It is important to inform them and think about the story you will tell them. Why is our project important for the consumer? Does it ensure better/safer dairy products or will the dairy products be of a higher quality?
+
Jeantine also mentioned that the end user of dairy products is in our case a very low stakeholder. This definitely does not mean we should set them aside. It is crucial to inform them and assess how we best should sell our vision.
The most important and helpful thing she told us was to make clear at all cases that our diagnostic tool will not get into the food! Only one small mentioning of this of one of the team members could make the headlines and break your story. Possibly the team’s project would only get remembered by the negative attention it got. Ultimately, chances of getting the product on the market would be close to zero. Tip: one team, one voice!  
+
Why is our project important for the consumer?  
 +
Does it ensure better/safer dairy products or will the dairy products be of a higher quality?
 +
She also highlighted the importance to clarify that our diagnostic tool will not have contact with the food!
 +
Even a small notion of GMO contamination in a food factory will significantly upset the public.
 +
That could result in having the entire project tainted in negativity. Such a negative press coverage and connotation would significantly reduce acceptance in the public as well as resulting in a reduced interest from industry due to PR issues. Ultimately, chances of getting the product on the market would be close to zero. Tip: one team, one voice!  
 
</div>
 
</div>
 
<hr class="small">
 
<hr class="small">
Line 80: Line 84:
 
<button onclick="accordion('acc6')" class="w3-button w3-block"><h3>Martin Goedhart & Maaike de Heij - 11 July </h3></button>
 
<button onclick="accordion('acc6')" class="w3-button w3-block"><h3>Martin Goedhart & Maaike de Heij - 11 July </h3></button>
 
<div id="acc6" class="w3-hide" style="text-align:left;">
 
<div id="acc6" class="w3-hide" style="text-align:left;">
Before the meeting with prof. Martin Goedhart and dr. Maaike de Heij we tried to contact multiple dairy factories and farmers, but all with no success. The fact that we are using a GMO for our project was probably one of the main factors why this was so difficult. Professor Martin Goedhart and dr. Maaike de Heij gave us great tips about how we should contact companies with our GMO product. After we implemented their advice, we were able to gain contact more easily. One of the researchers at a big dairy company was even surprised we were allowed to visit one of their factories!
+
Before the meeting with Prof. Martin Goedhart and Dr. Maaike de Heij we tried to unsuccessfully contact multiple dairy factories and farmers. The GMO nature of our system seemed to be the most likely reason for this failure to establish a proper line of communication. Professor Martin Goedhart and Dr. Maaike de Heij gave us great tips on how we should approach companies. After implementing their advice, we were able to achieve contact more easily. One of the researchers at a big dairy company was even surprised we were allowed to visit one of their factories!
 
</div>
 
</div>
 
<hr class="small">
 
<hr class="small">
Line 86: Line 90:
 
<button onclick="accordion('acc7')" class="w3-button w3-block"><h3 id="rob-duba">Rob Duba – 8 september</h3></button>
 
<button onclick="accordion('acc7')" class="w3-button w3-block"><h3 id="rob-duba">Rob Duba – 8 september</h3></button>
 
<div id="acc7" class="w3-hide" style="text-align:left;">
 
<div id="acc7" class="w3-hide" style="text-align:left;">
To gain insights into the current legislation and policy with regard to biotechnology, we contacted Rob Duba, a senior policy officer on Biotechnology at the Department of I&M. We learned that both the license for working with GMOs and notification at Bureau GGO is publicly available. If our biosensor is deemed restricted use, it is necessary for the company to have earned a license for working with GMOs and to have a Biosafety Officer no matter what. Unfortunately up to this moment, no GMO biosensor exists that was not categorized for restricted use. Only in the case that the biosensor gets an EU market approval (in Dutch: EU Markttoelating), which basically allows GMOs that are deemed safe to be released in nature, a company using it is not obliged to get a license.  
+
To gain insights into the current legislation and policy with regard to biotechnology, we contacted Rob Duba, a senior policy officer on Biotechnology at the Department of I&M. We learned that both the licensing for working with GMOs and notification at Bureau GGO is publicly available. If our biosensor is deemed for restricted use, it is necessary for the company to have applied for a GMO license as well as requiring designated Biosafety personal. Unfortunately, up to this moment, no GMO biosensor exists that was not categorized for restricted use. Only in the unlikely case that the biosensor gets an EU market approval (in Dutch: EU Markttoelating), which essentially allows GMOs that are deemed safe to be released in nature, a company using it is not obliged to get a license.  
 
</div>
 
</div>
 
<hr class="small">
 
<hr class="small">
Line 92: Line 96:
  
 
<blockquote><p class="quotation">  
 
<blockquote><p class="quotation">  
  If our product leads to less milk spoilage, would that mean farmers can sell less milk?
+
If our product leads to less milk spoilage, would that mean farmers can sell less milk? Would it drive down the cost of milk?
During the beginning of our project we asked this question to ourselves. We want our product to be good for everyone. We asked this question to two big dairy companies and one small farmer. Everyone was quite clear about this; no! Especially at the factory they told us that the more cheese they can make, the better. If they lose less product, that does not mean they will buy less milk.
+
During the beginning of our project, we asked ourselves this question. We want our product to be beneficial for everyone.  
 +
To gain some perspective we shared our worries with two big dairy companies and a small dairy farmer. Everyone was quite clear about this; no! Especially at the factory they told us that the more cheese they can make, the better. If they lose less product, that does not mean they will buy less milk, just a larger profit margin.
 
<footer></footer>
 
<footer></footer>
 
</p></blockquote>
 
</p></blockquote>

Revision as of 13:10, 16 October 2017


Silver Human Practices

At the beginning of our iGEM adventure we were invited by the Rathenau Institute, an institute which promotes safe and ethical research, to visit their introduction to the iGEMmers "Guide To The Future" (link)?. We also participated speed dates with Human Practices experts from the Rathenau and RIVM (government institute for health and environment). Before this event, we decided on making a DNA detection system. We were still unsure on the different aspects of implementation. After evaluating several options, receiving critical feedback and advice from experts in their respective fields we decided to focus on one specific project; a bacteriophages detection system for the dairy industry. We made use of the iGEMmers guide during the beginning of our project to explore our human practices opportunities with a skype call with Zoe Robaey. She guided us on where to start, who to contact, and how to design our 'Outbreak!' game.

To gain insights of the impact of using GMOs in the food industry we contacted Dr. J. Hille, among others, a lecturer of Biotechnology course unit at the University of Groningen. Here we discussed the general differences between European and American legislation concerning GMO use and the public perception of GMOs in general. Dr. J. Hille was kind enough to give us useful directions and connections, such as Jeantine Lunshof and pointed us towards issues we should take into account before further advancing with our project.

Cathalijne van Beekvelt works for the ILT. This is the Dutch Inspection of Living environment and Transport. We saught information about the regulations that could limit our products use. She gave us the contact information of Rob Duba, who might be of further assistance regarding the regulative challenges.

Multiple times, we had contact with Jaco Westra from the RIVM. RIVM provided us with funding and in turn, we tried to work on an assignment to continuously improve upon security aspects of our project. The title of the assignment was ‘Thinking before doing’. We eventually presented all of the safety aspects, we believe to be of relevance, in a card game which is both fun and educative. You can read more about 'Outbreak!' *here link*. Jaco was our contact person during this safety assignment. He gave great tips on how to handle legislation and on further points of contact, such as Wouter Ghering and ILT.

Jeantine Lunshof works as a bioethicist at the Church laboratory in Boston. We contacted her in the beginning of our project to educate ourselves on ethical dimensions in the field of synthetic biology. After introducing general idea of our project, she told us something about her work at the Church lab. Together we thought about a story which would be interesting as well as not repulsive for the public. Jeantine also mentioned that the end user of dairy products is in our case a very low stakeholder. This definitely does not mean we should set them aside. It is crucial to inform them and assess how we best should sell our vision. Why is our project important for the consumer? Does it ensure better/safer dairy products or will the dairy products be of a higher quality? She also highlighted the importance to clarify that our diagnostic tool will not have contact with the food! Even a small notion of GMO contamination in a food factory will significantly upset the public. That could result in having the entire project tainted in negativity. Such a negative press coverage and connotation would significantly reduce acceptance in the public as well as resulting in a reduced interest from industry due to PR issues. Ultimately, chances of getting the product on the market would be close to zero. Tip: one team, one voice!

Before the meeting with Prof. Martin Goedhart and Dr. Maaike de Heij we tried to unsuccessfully contact multiple dairy factories and farmers. The GMO nature of our system seemed to be the most likely reason for this failure to establish a proper line of communication. Professor Martin Goedhart and Dr. Maaike de Heij gave us great tips on how we should approach companies. After implementing their advice, we were able to achieve contact more easily. One of the researchers at a big dairy company was even surprised we were allowed to visit one of their factories!

To gain insights into the current legislation and policy with regard to biotechnology, we contacted Rob Duba, a senior policy officer on Biotechnology at the Department of I&M. We learned that both the licensing for working with GMOs and notification at Bureau GGO is publicly available. If our biosensor is deemed for restricted use, it is necessary for the company to have applied for a GMO license as well as requiring designated Biosafety personal. Unfortunately, up to this moment, no GMO biosensor exists that was not categorized for restricted use. Only in the unlikely case that the biosensor gets an EU market approval (in Dutch: EU Markttoelating), which essentially allows GMOs that are deemed safe to be released in nature, a company using it is not obliged to get a license.

If our product leads to less milk spoilage, would that mean farmers can sell less milk? Would it drive down the cost of milk? During the beginning of our project, we asked ourselves this question. We want our product to be beneficial for everyone. To gain some perspective we shared our worries with two big dairy companies and a small dairy farmer. Everyone was quite clear about this; no! Especially at the factory they told us that the more cheese they can make, the better. If they lose less product, that does not mean they will buy less milk, just a larger profit margin.